Virtual Reality - Without the Hype

You've hopefully noticed that we've tried to be pretty diligent on this web site by talking about "immersive 3D/VR" rather than just "virtual reality" (VR). The reason for that is whilst we love VR and think that it has real merits in certain situations we also think that from a practical training and learning point of view you are best off having VR as an option, NOT as the ONLY way to do the training.

The panels below summarise the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.

LaunchHardHat.JPG

Immersive 3D

Think first person shooter and other games - the user has an ordinary computer/tablet/smartphone but sees a 3D rendered environment which they can explore and interactive with either in third-person mode (so they see their avatar) or in first-person mode.

Pros

  • Almost every learner already has access to a suitable device

  • No issues with nausea

  • Many used to the interaction model from gaming

  • Can do long exercises, from 1 hour to 6 hours or more!

  • Can use anywhere (e.g. on bus, in cafe, on train, on sofa watching TV)

  • Can easily type test for text-chat

  • Can easily read text on in-world screens

Cons

  • Physical surroundings can distract from what is on the screen

  • Can look away to physical surroundings for support if gets too intense

  • Don't get a good sense of sizes

  • Not as big a Wow factor to engage some users

BU_emmawilliams.jpg

Virtual Reality

The users uses some form of headset and all they see is what is shown in that headset. See below for more information of headset options, and how VR differs from AR and MR.

Pros

  • No risk of distraction

  • Can make experiences VERY visceral - so good if modelling high -stress situations

  • Great if you use a headset for the task in real life (e.g. breathing apparatus)

  • Get a real sense of size and proportion

  • Huge Wow factor to engage users

Cons

  • Dedicated devices, expensive but getting cheaper (see Devices below)

  • Can cause nausea in some people (we reckon 10-20% of users may have issues)

  • Can cause problems for some glasses wearers

  • Most people become disorientated after 10-20 minutes or so, so keep exercises short

  • Since the user can't see the physical world they need to be in a safe and secure space, and probably have a "spotter" to watch them

  • Hard to type for text-chat or NPC avatar interactions - have to use pick-lists until voice good enough

  • Can be hard to read text on in-world screens and displays - particularly in small rooms

By default any training created by Trainingscapes will be available on both immersive 3D platforms (i.e. almost any PC, Mac, tablet or smartphone) and on Oculus VR devices (we're looking at HTC and other support in 2019). You might though want to design exercises slightly differently though if you expect the majority of users will be on VR given some of the limitations of VR. But the big advantage of Trainingscapes is that it lets you take an iterative approach, you don't have to decide now, you can author for both, try in both, and then iterate until you have a great piece of learning!

VR Devices
 

Quite apart from the range of different manufacturers (Oculus, HTC, Samsung, Google etc) there are also a range of different virtual reality headset types. Here is a quick summary of the main types out there - in order of rising cost! Note: In the last couple of years we have seen a real shake-out in the industry, and so the cheaper solutions like Google Cardboard, slip-in headsets and even 3DOF headsets like the Oculus Go are no longer promoted or supported, but the emergence of devices like the Oculus Quest has meant that integrated, tetherless devices are a lot cheaper (and more usable) than their tethered cousins and give a superb experience.

Untethered Integrated 6DOF Headsets

c. £299-400

These are the holy grail of VR headsets. Typified by the Oculus Quest this has 6DOF (degrees of freedom) tracking, so it knows if you are peering in or kneeling down, and it tracks the hand controllers (and even hands), and all of this without any external sensors. Set up is quick and easy - 30 seconds or so, but otherwise it's a go anywhere bit of VR kit (we even us it in the garden!).

Tethered Headsets

IMG_9503.jpg

c. £600 + £1000 PC

The VR rush started with the Oculus Rift and was soon joined by the HTC Vive. Both use a beefy PC (gaming specs, so £1000 plus) to actually run the applications, the headset is purely for display. 1 or 2 sensors provide "desk-scale" 6DOF movement tracking for the Rift, and 4 sensors provide room-scale tracking for the Vive (but think of the safety issues!).  The cord from the headset to the PC is a real trip hazard, but wireless solutions are available. Until the Quest arrives the only reasonable choice for commercial VR, assuming that Daydream and Gear VR are fading.

VR vs 360 vs MR vs AR
 

One of the big issues with VR is that it can mean different things to different people, and is also often confused with things like 360 video, Augmented Reality (AR) and Mixed Reality (MR). Here's our quick guide to the differences. Note that Trainingscapes is currently only designed to work with "true" VR.

IMG_9330.jpg

Virtual Reality

You only see what is Digital

Virtual Reality is where you don a headset and all you can see is what is being generated by that headset. You have no sense of the physical world around you and are mentally and emotionally transported to a new location and experience. Whilst "traditionally" you've had to download experiences to headsets to experience VR, the emerging WebXR standard lets you enter a fully-fledged VR experience from an ordinary web page using a VR headset's browser - see our WebXR demo.

CMV Photosphere - Waterfall - NormalMode

360 Image and Photo Virtual Reality

You only see what is Digital, but you can't move!

USes a VR headset (any type), but effectively puts you into the middle of a giant sphere, the inside walls of which are a "360" (actually 720) degree photo (used to be called a bubble-photo) or video. In the earliest versions you could just look around, but nowadays you can embed hotpots so as to pull up descriptions, audio or 2D video or jump to a  new sphere. Ideal for things like estate agents tours and some historical tours, but lack of agency limits the applications somewhat. There is some potential to run 360 photosphere alongside proper VR 3D content - should be do'able in Trainingscapes. One issue with a lot of 360 stuff is that you only want to look in one direction anyway - so why bother with 360/720, and with 360 video it can be very nauseous when you are looking one way but the cameraman goes off in another!

Mountain1.JPG

Augmented Reality

Pasting Digital onto the Physical

In conventional AR you look at your phone or tablet screen as though taking a photo or vide, but what you see has some form of digital asset laid on top of it. Pokemon Go is the most well-known example. You can get marker (and marker-less) AR where the digital asset is pasted over the top of (or anchored to) a marker image (as in our photo, good for putting furniture in rooms or bringing up explainer graphics), and geo-spatial AR where the digital asset location is linked to some real-world GPS or postcode location (we are working on a project like that for battlefield interpretation).

hololens_minecraft.jpg

Mixed Reality

Embedding Digital into the Physical

With Mixed Reality headsets such as Microsoft's Hololens and the Magic Leap you view reality directly through a visored headset, but 3D digital assets are displayed on the visor in such a way that they seem to be anchored in and aware of the 3D space you are looking at.  So for instance if you push a virtual glass of water off the table it will fall onto the floor. The future scope is incredible and a good complement to VR but current systems have very narrow fields of view - don't be taken in by the Microsoft marketing shot!

cave2.jpg

CAVEs and 3D Displays

White elephants?

We suppose they have their uses but they tend to be big ticket prestige installations that can be shown off to visitors, rather than getting everyday use by everyone as is possible with immersive 3D and even VR.  In a simple cave the user stands in a room where all 3, 4 , 5 or 6 sides are digital projection. In more advanced versions the user wears a set of 3D glasses (old-skool colour or polarisation style) so they get a sense of depth - and can even have objects in the middle of the room. Large single screen versions also available. Often though only one person sees the "true" picture, and others get a distorted view. Simple CAVEs can be great creative spaces though for art or for working with young kids or with some learning disabilities.

© 2019 Daden Limited. Created with Wix.com

Privacy  | Terms

  • Twitter Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • YouTube Social  Icon
  • Vimeo Social Icon